Table of Contents

  • Most common materials for cookware
  • How are cast iron and carbon steel alike?
  • What is the difference between cast iron and carbon steel?
  • Recipes that are better cooked with cast iron
  • Recipes that are better cooked with carbon steel
  • A few last words on carbon steel vs. cast iron cookware

Similarities

  • Both need to be cleaned with warm water, dried well, and coated with oil.
  • Both need to be seasoned to build up non-stick properties and prevent rusting.
  • Both transfer seamlessly from the stovetop, broiler, oven, grill, or over the crackling flames of a camping fire.
  • Neither should be exposed to acidic ingredients for long periods. (Brief and careful use on well-seasoned pans is OK.)

Differences

  • Carbon steel heats up and cools down more quickly.
  • Cast iron has better heat-retention capabilities.
  • Carbon steel pans are slightly lighter.
  • Cast iron pans have a thicker layer of seasoning.
  • Carbon steel pans usually have longer handles and sloped edges.
  • Cast iron usually has more vertical sides and shorter handles.